Book editing is a crucial step in the publishing process, but it can also come with its own set of problems. Here are 7 common problems with book editors and tips on how to combat them:


Problem 1: Lack of Communication


One of the most common problems with book editors is a lack of communication. This can happen when an editor is not responsive to emails or phone calls, or when they are slow to return revisions.

To combat this problem, it’s important to establish clear lines of communication with your editor from the start. Set expectations for response times and make sure you have their contact information readily available. It’s also a good idea to keep a record of all communication in case there are any misunderstandings later on.


Problem 2: Inconsistent Feedback

Another common problem with book editors is inconsistent feedback. This can happen when an editor gives contradictory or confusing feedback, or when they focus too much on one aspect of the book and ignore others.

To combat this problem, it’s important to ask for detailed and specific feedback. Ask your editor to provide examples of what they mean and to explain why they are suggesting certain changes. It’s also a good idea to ask for feedback on multiple rounds of revisions to ensure that the book is well-rounded and polished.


Problem 3: Lack of Expertise


A book editor who lacks expertise in a certain genre or subject matter can be a problem, as they may not be able to provide the level of feedback and revisions needed to improve the book.

To combat this problem, research and find an editor with experience and expertise in your book’s genre or subject matter. Ask for references or samples of their work, and be sure to ask about their experience and qualifications.


Problem 4: Conflicting Personalities


Personalities can clash, and this can lead to problems when working with a book editor. This can happen when an editor’s style or communication style does not align with the author’s.

To combat this problem, it’s important to find an editor whose personality and communication style aligns with yours. Schedule a meeting or phone call to get a sense of their personality and communication style before signing a contract.


Problem 5: Unforeseen Costs


Book editors may charge for additional services, such as additional rounds of revisions or formatting, which can add up quickly.

To combat this problem, make sure you understand the terms of your contract with the editor and ask for a detailed breakdown of costs. Be sure to budget for any additional services that may be needed.


Problem 6: Delayed Deadlines


Book editors may not meet the deadlines they have set, which can delay the publishing process.

To combat this problem, set clear deadlines and expectations with your editor at the start of the process. Be sure to keep track of the deadlines and communicate with your editor if there are any delays.


Problem 7: Unsatisfactory Results


Despite all the efforts, an editor may not be able to deliver the results that an author expected.

To combat this problem, it’s important to have clear goals and expectations for the book from the start. Communicate these goals to


In conclusion, book editing is a crucial step in the publishing process but it can also come with its own set of problems. From lack of communication, inconsistent feedback, lack of expertise, conflicting personalities, unforeseen costs, delayed deadlines and unsatisfactory results. However, by understanding and being aware of these common problems, authors can take steps to minimize them. By establishing clear lines of communication, asking for detailed and specific feedback, researching and finding an editor with experience and expertise, setting clear deadlines and goals, and budgeting for additional services, authors can ensure that the professional book editing services process runs smoothly and the final product meets their expectations.

What qualifications do book editors have?

Most book editors have a bachelor’s degree in English, journalism, or communications. Some also have a master’s degree, like an MFA in creative writing or literature. They may also have certifications from groups like the Editorial Freelancers Association (EFA) or the Board of Editors in the Life Sciences (BELS). They know about grammar, punctuation, and style, and they can give authors helpful feedback and work closely with them to improve their manuscripts.

Do book editors get paid?

Most of the time, book editors do get paid for their work. How much they get paid depends on the project, the publisher, and how experienced the editor is.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *